Designed and simulated · not yet made

A birch-sap holder, moulded or in stainless.

Libertu sells birch-sap kits in Latvia and asked if the bag holder could be moulded. We designed it two ways: moulded acetal (POM-C), or stainless pipe that needs no mould.

We simulated both under a full bag. A design review checks your part the same way.

The moulded holder on a birch trunk in a snowy forest: a brown rounded body with a grooved strap handle on top and a clear bag of sap hanging below it.
The moulded version with its strap handle, rendered on the pose from the in-use simulation.

See the bag fill on the tree.

Drill a 7 mm hole, fit the spile (the tap in the tree), and hang the holder on it. Here is the stainless version in three steps, from an empty bag to 9 L. Drag the slider, or pick a step to play it.

The round-tube holder hung on a birch spile, its handle on top and a full sap bag hanging from the slot underneath.
9.0 L of sap Drag the model to turn it.Swipe the model sideways to turn it.
  1. Fit the bag to the ring

    Drop the bag through the ring and fold its edge over the rim. Ring and bag slide into the tube from the end.

  2. Hang the holder on the spile

    The keyhole in the tube goes over the spile and drops onto its collar. The handle stays free.

  3. Let the tree fill it

    Sap drips from the spile into the bag. The weight of the sap keeps the fold on the ring, up to 9 L.

The holder parts are the CAD. The bag shapes come from a membrane simulation at eight volumes up to 9 L, blended between them. The creases above the sap, the rounded corners, the ripples and the hand moves are drawn. The design loads assume 10 L, so they sit on the safe side of this 9 L.

Designed for 100 N on the tree, 200 N in the hand.

Sap drips into a plastic bag held open inside the holder.

When the bag is full, it goes to the car by hand, so the holder carries twice the weight for that walk.

The two designs side by side. SF is the safety factor: the material's allowable stress over the peak stress found by finite element analysis (FEA). Pass line 1.10.
PropertyMouldedStainless
PartsBody and bandTube and ring
MaterialPOM-C, 4 mm wall304 pipe, Ø48.3 × 2 mm
ToolingInjection mouldsNo mould
Carry handleStrap, moulded with the bodyBar, welded to the tube
Safety factor, hanging 100 N1.271.15
Close view of the moulded holder from above: a brown plastic body with a grooved strap handle on its rounded top, the band at the open end and the clear bag folded over it.
The strap in one piece with the body, the band at the open end and the 60 µm bag below. Bag and band sit on the pose from the in-use simulation.

Moulded: two POM-C parts.

The finding that set the material: plain PP fails at 4 mm in FEA. POM-C at the same wall passes hanging, the bag fold and carrying.

A body and a band, both moulded. The bag goes down through the band and folds back over its rim.

  • 4 mm walls in POM-C, a food-contact acetal.
  • A strap handle in one piece with the body: 120 mm between the legs, 34 mm of finger room, a 30 mm wide grip with R3 edges.
  • Side grooves keep the strap section 11 mm thick and light, and the mould needs no slides for it.
  • A keyhole for the spile, clear of the handle.
  • Two lips at 135° hold the band; the bag leaves through the 16.5 mm gap between them.
  • The band is 631.9 mm round, so the bags Libertu uses today still fit.
Moulded holder. SF = allowable stress ÷ peak stress, pass line 1.10. Hanging uses the long-term strength of POM-C, as the bag hangs for weeks. The fold and carrying use its short-term strength.
CheckResult
FEA
POM-C 4 mm, hanging 100 N for 1,000 hoursSF 1.27
POM-C 4 mm, where the bag fold pulls on the lipsSF 1.56
POM-C 4 mm, carried 200 N by the strapSF 2.90
Plain PP 4 mm, no handle, for comparisonSF 0.48, fails
In-use simulation
Lean away from the tree when full, solved without the handle6°

One check is still open: the drop. From 1.5 m at −10 °C, our calculation takes the strap feet past yield, so it does not show the holder survives. First moulded parts need a physical drop test.

Stainless: a tube and a flat ring, no mould.

A mould has to be paid for before the first holder is sold. Stock stainless pipe needs no tooling of its own.

The tube is 304 stainless pipe, Ø48.3 × 2 mm, 310 long. A laser cuts the keyhole, the end cuts and a slot along the bottom. The ring is laser cut from flat 2 mm sheet. Neither part is bent.

The ring has the same 631.9 mm perimeter as the moulded band.

The bag goes through the ring and folds back over it. The excess hangs out through the slot, and the pressure of the sap keeps the fold on the ring.

The handle, our addition

A full bag is carried, so we added a handle and checked it like the rest. It is a Ø8 stainless bar, bent and TIG welded to the tube top, with a Ø30 plastic grip 120 mm long. A gloved hand has 40 mm under the grip.

The margin is thin: 1.12 on the ring and 1.15 on the tube, both simulated, neither yet tested.

Stainless holder with handle. For tube, ring and bar, SF = (205 MPa minimum yield of 304 ÷ 1.5) ÷ peak stress. The weld uses our assumed allowable: 0.6 × 205 ÷ 1.5 = 82 MPa. Pass line 1.10.
CheckResult
FEA
Tube peak stress, hanging, 304119.1 MPa, SF 1.15
Tube peak stress, carried 200 N99.2 MPa, SF 1.38
Ring, bag fold pulling on its edge121.8 MPa, SF 1.12
Simulation
Slot direction when hung0.5° from straight down
Frame calculation
Handle bar, carried 200 N81.8 MPa, SF 1.67
Hand calculation
Handle weld, 2 mm throat, carried 200 N27.8 MPa, SF 2.9
CAD
Clearance under the grip40 mm
Mass: tube, ring, handle, grip612 + 100 + 131 + 71 = 914 g

Have your part checked the same way.

Send a STEP file of your part, moulded, machined or sheet metal. A written report comes back, and every finding names its rule.

What we designed, what Libertu supplied

  • Ours: the moulded holder, the round-tube holder and its ring, the handle, the FEA, the CAD, the renders and this scene.
  • Libertu's: the kit, its spile and its bags.

The numbers come from CAD and simulation, and each is labelled.